Phillips Carbon - Pain continues..
I had written about Phillips Carbon some time ago. After that, the December 2012 quarterly result has come in. The company reported a totally subdued performance (to be honest, I was expecting a much worse result). I had mentioned some risks in the earlier write-up, many of which have started playing out. Following points may be noted:
- CBFS (raw material) prices continue to be high. Over the last one year, they have really spiked up. Although the carbon black prices have also increased, it has not been enough to cover the raw material price increase. The situation is not expected to improve anytime soon and one can expect the next 2-3 quarters to remain subdued. The following table gives a bit of perspective on the matter.
Ratio: Roughly 56 kg of carbon black can be obtained from 100 kg of CBFS. Prices given are blended of domestic as well as foreign and hence cannot give us a 100% perfect view.. * indicates approximate price.
- The company's power sales continue, but at lower realisations. Merchant power rates are also not exactly going through a great time.
- There is slowdown in the auto sector, which trickles down to a slowdown for the carbon black sector. The company is currently trying to develop its export sales, but given the slowdown in Europe and the China-angle, that seems quite difficult.
- There is an interesting comment in the Q3FY13 investor presentation. Post imposition of safeguard duty on Chinese carbon black, "imports in India from China have reduced, however, total imports in India continue to remain the same." :-) That's interesting!
- I believe the company will skip dividend this year/declare nominal dividend. So please dont look at the "5.3% dividend yield" based on last year's dividend, shown on most financial websites.
- Debt will prove a further drag on performance, specially in a cyclical downturn like the one at present.
- The current quarter result was not upto the mark due to certain one-time expenses charged during the quarter. Pension charges of Rs.20 cr and EDC, IDC charges of Rs.5 cr were charged during the quarter, due to which the profitability looks subdued.
- During the present FY, the company has purchased 3 additional land parcels (4 acres in Alwar, 4 acres in Lucknow and 2 acres in Ghaziabad) for a total of Rs.100 cr.
- The company has not yet booked any revenues for the New Okhla project. The booking will happen in FY14. In Q4FY13, the management expects to book Rs.100 cr revenue and Rs.33 cr PAT for their Gurgaon projects.
- In the PMC business, in case of any delay or quality issues in the construction etc, it is the contractor who is penalised if need be. NBCC has no liability on itself. Its position stays protected.
- For FY14, the management has guided PAT of Rs.225-250 cr.
- Company currently has Rs.1100 cr of cash, out of which Rs.300 cr is theirs and the rest are advances received.
- As per norms, the company has to distribute minimum 20% of the profits as dividend. NBCC has been paying out roughly 25%. On the guided profit, that works out to roughly Rs.5 dividend for FY14.
- Most importantly, when asked whether the PMC business may be opened up to non-government companies (in which case, NBCC's role will become irrelevant), the management seemed quite confident that under the existing structure, there is no visible threat of the same in the near future. This gives me quite some comfort.
1) All the posts on this blog, including this one, are for educational and discussion purposes only.
2) I post articles on individual stocks as well as varied topics like behavioural finance, industry analysis etc. None of the material posted should be regarded as advice to buy/sell any stock. My articles are not recommendations to buy/sell individual stocks, and should not be construed as any form of investment advice.
3) As a professional investor, I may have positions in stocks discussed.